"Independent sponsors do deal-by-deal because they failed to raise a fund."
- Recently heard misconception from a PE Titan (whose Family Office remains skeptical to investing in independent sponsors)
Independent sponsors prefer deal-by-deal because:
• Focus on the target companies, not the fund. A sponsor skews more towards the mindset of a business owner & operator versus a money manager. This manifests in decision-making and how their time is allocated on a weekly basis.
• Flexibility to invest in what they want (= no set mandate), customize cap tables for each deal (= more diversified), vary hold periods for each deal, and wait until the right opportunity emerges (= no pressure to deploy).
• There is more alignment with both capital partners (deal-level discretion) and business owners (economics are tied to the same vehicle).
• Economics aren't cross-collateralized. A bad deal doesn't compromise profits/carry from a good deal.
• Resilience of receiving management fees from a diversified set of portcos is better than relying on the performance of the two most recent funds.
• Track record is at the deal-level, which is more relevant & specific, versus fund-level. A sponsor can legitimately point to 2-3 good deals + 1 bad deal, versus a blended average from a fund with the same holdings.
• Faster to make money. We recently exited a deal after 2 years, where the sponsor had earned significant carry. Few funds reach carry in the first 5 years.
• Fewer regulations (lower compliance burden). This in turn allows for a leaner operation & organization.
• Lifestyle-friendly. There's no need to administer a fund & associated team. If each portco is performing, the sponsor can govern from afar and without a centralized team.
Many independent sponsors are actually ideally positioned to raise a fund because of their experience & track record, but they don't because the IS model is superior for them.
Good luck.