Stand-alone independent sponsor deals as an investment alternative are illiquid, quite risky, and long term. Therefore they must project returns that are highly competitive, which means at least 20%, ideally closer to or above 30%.
Every investor knows a projection isn’t a promise, but a pro forma is nonetheless a thought-to-be-credible version of the future. A lower base case projection can be seen as conservative, which is good, but it simultaneously has to be high enough to tickle LPs’ fancy.
The rule of thumb is, of course, that a deal should be priced and underwritten to deliver a 5yr base case projection in the 25-35% range. If your assumptions fail to land you in this range, they may be too conservative or else your deal lacks sufficient upside potential (likely because the valuation is too high).
Experienced sponsors with strong track record can more easily get away with conservative assumptions, as their past returns suggest a certain likelihood of overperformance that will entice investors.